Disclosure: we all know Miles Morales is the real Spider-Man 2 but its lack of number would ruin the gag. But since you’re reading this, I just want you to know that you’re swell and sorry in advance for making fun of your favorite Spidey game, maybe
You may think that being arguably the best Spider-Man game ever made guaranteed Marvel Spider-Man 2’s top spot. In reality, it’s because it lives up to the number “2” better than any other title on this list by literally featuring two Spider-Men. That’s really all it takes, but somehow, only Insomniac understood the assignment. The game’s other high points, like the great action, incredible traversal, and strong writing, are just extra credit.